THE CLASSIC | NEW YORK CITY
Schmackary’s is a happy little cookie spot. It’s got a great atmosphere and even better cookies. They have so many different kinds that it’s hard to choose just one! Lucky for me, I’m focusing my efforts on chocolate chip. It makes these decisions a little easier. This chocolate chip was your beautiful, wonderful classic, hence its name. It has a little sea salt on top that balances the sweetness of the chips. It was chewy throughout with enough melted chocolate to make a mess. Just the way I like it!
Cookies from Schmackary’s are all about medium-sized. They’re not too rich, so you can eat more than one and not feel totally bad about yourself. With that said, my second cookie was the Peanut Butter Patty. MMM MMM! I love a good peanut butter and chocolate combo. And the ratio between the peanut butter cookie and creamy chocolate icing? Perfection.
With cookies like Schmackerdoodle, Sweet Corn, Cereal Killer and Maple Bacon, you’re going to need to take a few friends and try them all.
THE COOKIE TOUR STOP
My friends and I visited Schmackary’s after a Sunday matinee of Hello, Dolly! *Everyone, please take a moment to bow to the queen that is Bernadette.* Schmackary’s is just off of Times Square, and is the perfect place for a post- or pre-show treat. With a Broadway show and a trip to Schmackary’s, I was basically living my best New York life.
WHILE YOU’RE THERE
You’re right on the cusp of Hell’s Kitchen when you’re at Schmackary’s, so there is good food EVERYWHERE. We walked just one block over to 46th Street and had incredible hand made pasta at Becco. All three of us had the Sinfonia di Paste, which is tableside service of the chef’s three daily pastas. Oh, my. Unlimited pasta plus a salad to start. Becco is a true gem. Be careful how many rounds of pasta you have—you’ll want to save room for your Schmackary’s stop!
Schmackary’s is currently doing an online vote to see where their next location should be. OKC Cookie Tourists—let’s stuff that electronic ballot box and get that next location here! VOTE HERE!